Near my house is large, run-down mall. Once upon a time it may have been a nice mall but it’s hit hard times: lots of empty stores, very few customers, a general air of decay and neglect. Basically, it doesn’t have much to offer by way of shopping.
But, it does have a great big empty parking lot. A couple times a year the parking lot gets taken over by traveling fairs — you know, the kind that seem to have Death Trap spelled out in neon lights? I’m always amazed that there are still such fairs and that people still go to them — at least enough to keep them in business.
Also, there is a yearly circus that unfolds its tents in the mall parking lot.
I know that the circus is in town because, as I drive on the highway right by the mall, I look over and there, standing in the parking lot, are two elephants. They are underneath a small tent but it’s open on all sides so the elephants are plainly viewable.
I can’t even express the heart-pain it gives me to see these creatures in this environment. The image is burned into the retinas of my eyes: the small space of the tent, the way they just stand there, their heads bent, the blue plastic tarp over their heads, the asphalt beneath their feet.
The absolute wrongness of their location is maddening to me — and, I suspect, to them.
Animal rights activists are always accused of over sentimentalizing animals — so I won’t talk about the fact that elephants are incredibly intelligent creatures, that they have demonstrated a capacity for deep emotion and memory. I won’t mention that their ability to implement their circus “routines” might be further evidence of their ability to not just learn but to think and feel.
No matter what, they don’t deserve to be standing in the mall parking lot. Surely we can all agree?
My heart is broken for them.
Elephants as they should be.


6 comments
Comments feed for this article
August 7, 2008 at 11:37 pm
hilaire
Ugh. So awful.
I know exactly what you mean about how painful this is. I remember once seeing a little tiny 20-foot pool – part of a mini-circus on the beach in Barcelona – with two dolphins in it. All they did was “swim” neurotically up and down the length of those 20 feet. It was heartbreaking.
I can’t get over the fact that the scene you describe is even allowed.
August 8, 2008 at 12:55 am
Casey
Ach. It’s inhumane to make any sentient creature stand out in a hot parking lot. I’m with hilaire — it’s hard to believe such a thing is possible.
August 8, 2008 at 1:20 am
Notorious Ph.D.
That’s a beautiful elephant picture, and I’m sorry to hear of their counterparts stuck in a mall parking lot. Hell, I’m sorry to hear of *anyone* stuck in a mall parking lot.
True story: the summer I turned 17, I worked for a traveling carnival (sans circus) of the kind you described. It was an interesting summer, but I will *never* get on a carnival ride again. It’s not the rides that are the problem; it’s the hung-over ride operators.
August 8, 2008 at 1:21 am
ammcomms
Thank you for this lovely post. It’s so important that we notice — that we witness — the suffering of our fellow beings. Elephants and other wild animals in captivity can be treated like this because the law that regulates such things — the Animal Welfare Act — is weak and the agency that is supposed to enforce it — the US Agriculture Dept — lacks the resources and will to do it. But if we could get people to stop going to circuses that use animals, they would stop using them!
August 8, 2008 at 2:59 pm
squadratomagico
What a sad sight. Circuses shouldn’t have animals — they should just have lots of crazy people and weird costumes. You don’t need miserable animals in order to put on a great circus.
August 8, 2008 at 10:15 pm
The Bittersweet Girl
Yeah, Squadratomagico, I thought about your circus when I was writing this post. How I wish that there was a gender-fuck, experimental art, public exhibition circus near my house — the kind with great masks and no animals other than the human kind.