It’s only week four here at Mid-State U but my students are out-doing themselves with their stories of hardship and woe. A few outstanding entries in the Student Excuse category:
* Student X’s father was diagnosed with Alzheimer’s and s/he had to travel to hir family’s distant location to deal with medical care issues.
* Student X has family in the South and has to go there to help them evacuate.
* Student X is in the military and has to go to the South to help with the hurricane evacuation.
* Student X was the victim of a crime and has to go to court to deal with it but s/he’s got the crime report to show me to prove that it happened.
You’ll be thinking that I’m terribly callous to characterize any of these scenarios as fictions … but what if I told you that Student X was one individual? Suddenly seems like a perfect storm of bad luck, doesn’t it?
But here’s the real winner:
Student Y has to miss class because hir sister is giving birth … and feels necessary to add that Student Y’s Sister had gone through a traumatic birth last year in which she gave birth to multiple babies but none survived. To prove that Student Y is not making up this terrible story, s/he provides a link to a website about the death of the babies but warns me that it includes graphic pictures.
WTF? Is Student Y really purchasing an excused absence with pictures of hir deceased nieces/nephews? Am I really supposed to have such a prurient curiosity that I would click on the link and scroll around in someone else’s misery?
These students need to chill with the excuses.

5 comments
Comments feed for this article
September 17, 2008 at 5:12 pm
disenchanted
Good grief. My best excuse ever was the student who told me that her parents had her committed to the mental hospital because they were afraid she might kill herself after she found out she had herpes.
Every time I saw her after that, all I could think of was “Herpes Girl!”
September 17, 2008 at 7:26 pm
deb
Yowsa!! And it is only September still!
I tell my students they each get one absence, no questions asked.
Anything beyond that requires a doctor’s note to be “excused.
I find it cuts down on the amount of Jerry Springer I have to listen to.
September 17, 2008 at 9:07 pm
The Bittersweet Girl
Deb, I give my students TWO excused absences, no questions asked. So why they are plying me with such extravagant stories is anyone’s guess. My whole goal with this policy was precisely to control the Jerry Springer effect — to no avail.
September 19, 2008 at 3:56 pm
kfluff
For the first time ever, I got the “dog ate my homework” excuse. With the gnawed binder to “prove” it. When in doubt, go with a winner, I say.
September 23, 2008 at 7:41 pm
historiann
Yeah, this is why I tell my students that I don’t do “excused absences.” They can miss up to four classes (on a MWF schedule) for whatever reason, legitimate or illegitimate, but if they miss more than four classes they forfeit all of their class participation grade (30% of the final grade). I have to miss a few Fridays this term to travel to conferences, so I don’t think that this is too draconian. (I may be wrong.)
I don’t really care why students miss (or skip) class. They’re either there, or they’re not. And, I don’t really want to hear their excuses or try to sort out the legitmate from the illegitimate ones.
That excuse that disenchanted reports is Exhibit A for why I just don’t want to know.