Fairly spoiler-free review, I promise.
Sci-fi geeks have reason to celebrate! The new Star Trek movie is great fun — it manages to incorporate just enough of the familiar to satisfy long time Trek fans (of which I am one) with just enough of the big summer blockbuster aesthetic (can you say, “explosions”?) to be entertaining.
I have never been a huge Kirk fan (my heart belongs to Picard, thank you very much) so I don’t have a stake in the “can he replace Shatner?” debate — but I thought that overall the casting was the high point of the film. The actors were beautiful to look at and enjoyable to see in these new/old roles. Yes, I was even able to forget Sylar when I watched Zachery Quinto playing young Spock. There are a couple of poor casting choices in terms of minor characters — including one egregious “Cornel West in The Matrix” moment that will make you scratch your head and wonder what the hell they were thinking — but overall, I give the film and the acting high marks.
Unfortunately, feminist sci-fi geeks have less to be excited about. There is a conspicuous lack of female characters and the ones there are fall into one of two classic categories: loving but doomed or inexplicably absent mothers or love interests/sex objects. There has been an attempt made to give Uhura an actual area of expertise, rather than just being a glorified telephone operator, but she still doesn’t do much except be ogled at by one male lead or gaze affectionately at another. And yes, she’s still in the micro-mini skirt — when she’s not in her underwear. Sigh. Given that so much of contemporary sci-fi is dominated by ass-kicking females (Starbuck, Echo, that Terminator chick), you’d think they could have given Uhura some previously unknown fighting skills. But, I hope that now that this origin story is done, the film makers can put a little bit more thought into female characterization in the next film. (Are you listening, J.J. Abrams?)
In the end, though, I enjoyed the movie, enjoyed being back in that universe I know so well, and watching it with a huge laughing and applauding crowd who got all the in-jokes (red shirt, anyone?) made it all the more fun.

5 comments
Comments feed for this article
May 15, 2009 at 12:01 pm
Boldly going forward, ’cause we can’t find reverse? : Historiann : History and sexual politics, 1492 to the present
[...] The Bittersweet Girl writes, “[u]nfortunately, feminist sci-fi geeks have less to be excited about.” Hmmm–I wonder why: There is a conspicuous lack of female characters and the ones there are fall into one of two classic categories: loving but doomed or inexplicably absent mothers or love interests/sex objects. There has been an attempt made to give Uhura an actual area of expertise, rather than just being a glorified telephone operator, but she still doesn’t do much except be ogled at by one male lead or gaze affectionately at another. And yes, she’s still in the micro-mini skirt — when she’s not in her underwear. Sigh. Given that so much of contemporary sci-fi is dominated by ass-kicking females (Starbuck, Echo, that Terminator chick), you’d think they could have given Uhura some previously unknown fighting skills. But, I hope that now that this origin story is done, the film makers can put a little bit more thought into female characterization in the next film. (Are you listening, J.J. Abrams?) [...]
May 15, 2009 at 2:52 pm
Ink
I am dying to see this. Great review!
May 15, 2009 at 4:02 pm
GayProf
Your review is great and to the point.
If the producers wanted to be bold, they could have converted some of the sixties male characters into women (akin to BSG’s changes). Alas, that didn’t seem to cross their minds.
May 20, 2009 at 7:00 pm
Star Trek and the Male Imagination - The Pursuit of Harpyness
[...] other blogs have covered the new film’s gender trouble, or perhaps more accurately put, its [...]
May 22, 2009 at 5:28 pm
Karen
Nice review! I agree completely about Zachery Quinto. I was skeptical at first but I thought he did such a great job acting that I completely forgot who the actor was and focused on the character.